Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Red Desert

Il deserto rosso; art-film / psychological drama, Italy / France, 1964; D: Michelangelo Antonioni, S: Monica Vitti, Richard Harris, Carlo Chionetti, Xenia Valderi

Ravenna. Ever since she had a traffic accident, Giuliana is feeling anxiety and depression. She lives with her husband Ugo, an engineer at a petrochemical plant, and son Valerio. Ugo meets her with industrialist Corrado, who is recruiting workers who will travel to Patagonia. Corrado is infatuated with Giuliana and tries to understand her delirious state. They go to a hut at the dock with Max, Linda and Emilia where they joke, surrounded by fog. Valerio seems to have lost his ability to feel his legs, but later on walks again. Giuliana goes to Corrado's hotel room to have an affair, but eventually changes her mind. She talk to a sailor at the dock and asks if she can board the ship, but he doesn't speak her language, so she stays. 

"Red Desert" is one of several overrated films by director Michelangelo Antonioni: it speaks about the alienation of modern technological times, where people who are not accustomed to this cold world with lack of interhuman contact fall into anxiety and neurosis, but the whole film is not able to articulate this into a better, more cohesive story which just meanders from episode to episode, not connecting into some sort of a unifying point at the end. Overlong and overstretched, "Red Desert" suffers from Antonioni's typical trope of a protagonist feeling anxiety and depression, but not elaborating to make a serious case study about it. The best bits are during some "tight" interactions between characters, such as when Corrado and Giuliana observe an estuary where a petrochemical plant dumps its waste, and thus the environment feels dead, black and polluted, which reminds Ugo of a man who "complained that his eel tastes like petroleum". Another is the scene where Giuliana asks Corrado if he is left-wing or right-wing, and he gives a surprisingly philosophical answer: "One believes in humanity, in a certain sense. A little less in justice. A little more in progress... What matters is to act as one thinks right - right for oneself and for others". The aesthetic images of factories and landscapes (the impressive frame of trees in the foreground, as suddenly a giant ship is passing by in the background; the story about a girl on the beach filmed in the stunning blue sea), or just certain filming types (the scene of the Giuliana watching five people "disappear" in the fog on the dock) create a good mood. However, for a psychological drama, the main protagonist Giuliana is disappointingly thin, since we ultimately do not find out much about her motivations or emotions, except the standard anxiety trope. Antonioni uses long scenes of empty walk to again conjure up the feeling on emptiness in life, but this does get a bit boring in the process. 

Grade:++ 

No comments: