The Boys; fantasy-thriller series, USA, 2020, D: Phil Sgriccia, Liz Friedlander, Steve Boyum, Fred Toye, Batan Silva, S: Karl Urban, Antony Starr, Jack Quaid, Erin Moriarty, Dominique McElligott, Aya Cash, Jessie T. Usher, Laz Alonso, Tomer Capone, Karen Fukuhara
Billy “Butcher” returns to Hughie, Marvin and Frenchie. They are hunted down by the superheroes led by Homelander, but manage to escape. Homelander finds out the new superhero among the ranks of Seven, Stormfront, is actually a woman born in Berlin over a century ago, as her husband Vought performed Nazi eugenics experiments, which was continued by the Vought corporation that aims to create superhumans via their Compound 5. Stormfront and Homelander start an affair. A-Train, angry that he will be excluded from the Seven upon Stormfront’s insistence because he is black, hands over this confidential documentation to Hughie and Annie, aka Starlight. They in turn send it to the media. Billy reunites with Becca, but she refuses to leave without her son Ryan. Billy and the gang try to trick Homelander into leaving Ryan’s house while they take away Ryan, but then Stormfront appears and starts chocking Becca. In panic, Ryan’s superpowers activate and his laser kills Stormfront, but accidentally also Becca. Billy still decides to take care of Ryan.
The 2nd season of “The Boys” is a step back compared to the better first one. It seems the authors wrote themselves into a corner on at least three times, so they resorted to convoluted, forced resolutions to save their protagonists. At the end of the first season, Homelander brought Billy to see Becca again, at her house. Why didn’t Homelander eliminate Billy right there? He just let’s Billy walk away, in a very lame example of screenwriting. Sure, Billy is framed for Madelyn's murder, but they could have still eliminated him outright and then released the accusation. Later, when Homelander finds Hughie in a sewer and orders Starlight to kill Hughie in episode 2.3, the resolution is also unconvincing, yielding to “deux ex machina” clichés. The sick tendency to show bizarre, random splatter violence and vile murders (in a shocking, traumatizing sequence, just as a doctor and former employee was about to testify against Vought at a hearing in episode 2.6, dozens of people’s heads start exploding in the room, compared to which even Cronenberg’s “Scanners” seem restrained), as well as bad ideas (The Deep hallucinating that his fins are talking to him in episode 2.2; the yacht running through a whale in episode 2.3), which takes its toll on the season. Unfortunately, the authors resorted to typical “shock engineering” to keep the viewers’ interest, which is already a bad sign. The reveal that Vought was created through Nazi eugenics experiments on people was a tad too banal, but lately it became actually relevant, as Stormfront is a symbol for the ever growing normalization of far-right tendencies and extremism in politics (she even mentions the term "white genocide").
Nonetheless, there are still some more intelligent, subversive and creative allegories on the modern era, which lift the season up a notch. One of the more subversive jabs is aimed at how any error or crime of those in power can simply be whitewashed by gaslighting the masses through social media and fake popularity conditioning, controlled by these same people in power. As superhero Stormfront explains to Homelander: “You don't need 50 million people to love you. You need five million people pissed. Emotion sells, anger sells”. That way, the fact that Vought corporation experimented with injecting Compound 5 substance into babies turns from a scandal to a patriotic necessity, redirecting the narrative into a polemic that many more potential future superheroes will make America stronger from supervillains wanting to attack them. Another layer of this theme can be interpreted in compliance and Faustian bargain, from Vought employees and even their CEO disagreeing with the corporation’s evil policies, yet still obeying and remaining passive because it is profitable. Billy thus stands out as someone with integrity, in an active existence, as opposed to them: he is powerless, but still has the courage to keep going. One episode is excellent—2.4—while others are either good or weak. One genius sequence in episode 2.7: when an ex-superhero sets himself on fire, this triggers a fire alarm, which inadvertently causes Annie to be released from her prison cell. In a battle, Black Noir overwhelms her, but then Queen Maeve puts a candy bar into Black Noir’s mouth, and he is suddenly weak. Maeve then explains to Annie that Black Noir has a peanut allergy, in a brilliant restructuring of the Kryptonite concept. Despite clumsy and heavy-handed moments, season 2 still works.
Grade:++









