Les Misérables; historical musical-drama, UK / USA, 2012; D: Tom Hooper, S: Hugh Jackman, Russell Crowe, Amanda Seyfried, Eddie Redmayne, Samantha Barks, Anne Hathaway, Sacha Baron Cohen, Helena Bonham Carter
Toulon, 1815. Convict Jean Valjean, sentenced for stealing bread, is released from a harbor penal prison by prison guard Javert. Valjean needs to report monthly to his parole officer. When he tries to steal silverware from a church, the priest tells the police that he gifted it to Valjean, so the moved Valjean decides to help people from there on. In 1823, Valjean is the mayor of a town and owner of a textile factory, living under a different name. A fired worker, Fantine, finds a new job as a prostitute to pay for her daughter, Cosette, but dies from starvation. Valjean brings up Cosette. In 1832, Marius falls in love with the now grown-up Cosette. The Republicans start the Paris June Rebellion in order to try to overthrow the monarchy led by King Louis Philippe I, but the army crushes them. Since Valjean spared his life when he was caught as a spy by the Republicans, Javert allows Valjean and Marius to escape alive. Marius and Cosette marry, while Valjean dies.
Tom Hooper's film adaptation of Victor Hugo's famous novel "Les Miserables" is a musical-drama that, paradoxically, would have worked much better just as a drama. All the performances would have been great if the forced singing wasn't in their way—while some musicals have isolated singing numbers and then take a "break" and return to being a straight drama for the next 10 minutes, "Les Miserables" consist of almost non-stop singing, even during the most ridiculous situations (singing while fencing, singing while dying, singing convicts pulling a rope in the sea...), since all this feels too unnatural and artificial, which hinders the enjoyment value of the storyline. The whole concept is misguided, since Hugo's novel shouldn't have been transformed into a musical in the first place. Nontheless, Hugo's story still offers a rare depiction of the attempted "Second French Revolution", when the 1832 June Rebellion tried to overthrow the monarchy to again resume the French Republic, showing a complicated set of characters who are fed up with poverty and low life quality, which all serve as a catalyst to try to improve their society. Anne Hathaway is outstanding as Fantine, but shockingly underused—her character dies already 42 minutes into the film, with only 20 minutes of screen time, which is simply too meagre and narrowed down. Hathaway's highlight: the emotional "I Dreamed a Dream" song filmed in one 4-minute take, which is incredible ("...life has killed the dream I dreamed..."). Sacha Baron Cohen is also amusing as the swindler Thenandier, who feigns he is caring for Fantine's daughter, calling her "Colette", while his wife immediately corrects him: "Cosette". Despite flaws, high production values, great cinematography and an emotional ending assure "Les Miserables" is a good film, if the viewers can "adjust" to its musical format.
Grade:++